top of page

Who Challenges the Person Making the Decisions?

 

Why experienced CEOs still need the opportunity to test their thinking

​

The further someone progresses in leadership, the greater the expectation that they will have the answers. They have accumulated experience, developed judgement, built relationships and earned the confidence of those around them. People look to them for direction, particularly when circumstances become difficult or uncertain.

Yet experience does not eliminate uncertainty, and seniority does not necessarily provide a better environment in which to explore it.

In my experience, one of the less visible challenges of leading a business is that the number of people with whom a CEO can speak openly often reduces as their responsibilities increase.

There may be a capable executive team, supportive board members and trusted professional advisers, but each relationship serves a different purpose. The leadership team is part of the organisation being discussed. The board has its own responsibilities and expectations. Professional advisers bring valuable expertise, but usually within a particular discipline or remit.

None of those relationships necessarily provides the opportunity for a leader to explore a difficult decision before they have settled on a position.

The value of being challenged

Throughout my career, both in executive leadership and working with business owners and senior leaders, I have seen how easy it is for a decision to become embedded before its underlying assumptions have been properly examined.

A leader may have considered an issue extensively and reached a conclusion that appears commercially sound. The people around them may agree, particularly when they have confidence in that leader's previous judgement. What remains uncertain is whether the alternatives have been sufficiently explored, the risks understood and the consequences considered beyond the immediate decision.

Constructive challenge is valuable precisely because it is not dependent on disagreement. Its purpose is to improve the thinking behind the decision, rather than to prove that someone has reached the wrong conclusion.

Sometimes that challenge strengthens the original position. At other times, it reveals an assumption that no longer holds, a risk that has been underestimated or an opportunity that deserves greater attention.

The important outcome is better judgement and greater confidence in the direction chosen.

Why peer experience matters

There is particular value in discussing leadership challenges with people who have carried comparable responsibilities.

Other CEOs may operate in entirely different markets, but many of the fundamental challenges are recognisable: developing leadership capability, balancing short-term performance with longer-term investment, maintaining standards through growth, managing the expectations of stakeholders and knowing when to intervene rather than delegate.

Their experience will not always provide a solution. Indeed, applying someone else's answer to a different business without understanding the circumstances can be dangerous.

What their experience can provide is perspective. Someone who has faced a similar situation may recognise a consequence that has not yet been considered, explain where their own judgement proved mistaken or challenge an assumption that others have accepted.

The quality of a peer discussion depends on the willingness of participants to be open, listen carefully and challenge each other constructively. It also requires a degree of confidentiality and trust that is not always available within normal business conversations.

When those conditions exist, the discussion moves beyond simply exchanging experiences and becomes a means of improving decision-making.

From discussion to action

A useful conversation should do more than leave a leader feeling reassured that other people face similar problems.

It should help establish what decision actually needs to be made, what evidence matters, which choices are available and who has responsibility for taking the next step.

This is an important distinction. Senior leaders can spend considerable time discussing an issue without making progress because the underlying decision has not been clearly defined.

In my mentoring work, the objective is not to take decisions away from the person responsible for them. It is to help them examine those decisions rigorously, identify what may be missing and move forward with greater clarity.

The best conversations combine commercial understanding, appropriate challenge and an appreciation of the realities of leading an organisation.

Creating space for better decisions

On 26 November, I will be facilitating a CEO peer-group session at Memcom's CEO Learning Lab in London, in partnership with the Association of Business Mentors.

The event brings together CEOs and senior leaders from membership organisations to discuss the challenges they face, share practical experience and benefit from constructive peer challenge.

I welcome the opportunity to contribute, particularly because the underlying principle extends well beyond any one sector.

Whether leading a membership organisation, an established SME or a rapidly growing business, there are times when the greatest value comes not from another report or another opinion, but from the opportunity to examine an important decision with someone who understands the responsibility of making it.

​

Commercial performance improves when decision quality improves. Creating the conditions for better decisions is therefore not an optional extra in leadership. It is an important part of leading well.

​

Mark O'Neil is a Strategic Business Mentor and founder of Kinetic Mentoring, working with founders, CEOs and boards on strategic decisions, leadership and business performance.

Further information: Memcom CEO Learning Lab 2026.

Kinetic Business Advice Limited is incorporated in England and Wales. Registered Number: 07807623.

Registered office  7-9 The Avenue,  Eastbourne  East Sussex BN21 3YA

ICO Registration ZB544242 

Kinetic Mentoring, Kinetic  Capital, Kinetic Foundation and Professional Business Mentoring are trading styles of Kinetic Business Advice Limited

SHIFT³: Clarity in Three Dimensions framework is a trademark of Kinetic Business Advice

​

bottom of page